What makes a good FRAEW? New government guidance on external wall fire risk

The Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government has published new guidance to help building owners, managing agents and residents understand fire risk appraisals of external walls (FRAEWs), including how to commission an appraisal and recognise a good-quality report.

The guidance is a welcome development, particularly in highlighting the importance of competent assessment, appropriate evidence and proportionate recommendations. However, recognising a good FRAEW requires more than checking whether a report contains the expected information.

An FRAEW undertaken in accordance with PAS 9980 may identify combustible materials, deficiencies in cavity barriers or other shortcomings in external wall construction. Such findings can be significant, but their presence does not automatically establish the level of fire risk or justify wholesale remediation.

The purpose of an FRAEW is to understand how the characteristics of the external walls influence the likelihood and consequences of fire spread, taking account of the building's particular circumstances and wider fire safety arrangements.

The distinction between identifying a defect and understanding its significance for fire risk is fundamental.

PAS 9980 provides a structured methodology, but its application requires competent professional judgement. Risk assessment matrices and scoring systems can support this process, but should not substitute for an understanding of fire behaviour, construction and credible fire scenarios.

Similarly, recommendations must be justified by the risks identified. A localised defect does not necessarily warrant extensive remediation, while apparently minor deficiencies may have significant consequences in particular circumstances.

A good appraisal should explain the relationship between the evidence, the assessment of risk and the measures recommended to address it. Uncertainties should be identified and their potential influence on the conclusions considered.

The government's guidance provides a useful framework for clients to question the quality and completeness of FRAEW reports. However, there is an important distinction between procedural completeness and technical competence.

A report may contain every expected heading and still fail to demonstrate sound technical reasoning. Equally, professional qualifications and experience, while essential considerations when appointing an assessor, do not themselves validate the conclusions reached.

The quality of an FRAEW ultimately depends on whether its findings and recommendations are evidence-based, technically defensible and proportionate.

The new guidance should help building owners and managing agents become better-informed clients. Above all, it reinforces the importance of understanding fire risk rather than simply cataloguing construction defects.

Good fire engineering is not just about identifying what could go wrong, but understanding its significance and making sound, proportionate decisions in response.

Further reading: MHCLG, Fire risk appraisals of external walls (FRAEWs), September 2026

Pyrology Insight provides commentary on contemporary fire safety topics. It is intended to stimulate professional discussion and should not be relied upon as project-specific advice.

Next
Next

Fire Safety Is Not Just About Getting People Out